George R. Kane
1938 – 1943

Stanley Mikula Jr.
1944 – 1945

Joseph Dowches
1946

George R. Kane
1947 – 1949

Thomas Quinta
1950 – 1952

Joseph Brogan Jr.
1953 – 1954

George Woodland Sr.
1955

John Mandeville Jr.
1956 – 1957

Daniel Budd
1958

Joseph Brogan Jr.
1959 – 1962

George R. Farley
1963 – 1965

Charles Brogan
1966 – 1968

Tony Dorsa
1969 – 1970

Charles Brogan
1971 – 1972

William Doyle (resigned)
1973 – 1975

Greg Kane
1975 – 1977

Norman Fernicola
1978

Gary Brogan
1979 – 1981

Carl Memel
1982 – 1983

Thomas Rezycki
1984 – 1985

James Farley
1986 – 1989

Carl Memel
1990 – 1991

James Farley
1992 – 1995

Matt DeCicco
1996 – 2003

Sean Taylor
2004 – 2007

Mike Wesolowski Jr.
2008 – 2011

Eric DeCicco
2012 - Present